Got mine today, well made (no surprises there!) tried with Surefire G2, Nextorch, Maglite 2D and 2AA Minimag and Tesco 3w aa torches, all of which fitted fine, certainly well enough to use at work. I guess that it would work with longer Maglites (d cell) but I'm not so sure that it would be so effective. Time will tell how tough the holder is but first impressions are positive. If you have several torches, this is ideal!